The way pie should be.
Our pies are made from scratch, baked fresh daily, & filled with the best seasonal flavors.

American Pies
We are passionate about our pie making. That's why we never take shortcuts.
Specialty Cakes
We offer quality special-occasion cakes in a variety of sizes and flavors, lovingly filled and decorated
Cupcakes & Treats
Cupcakes are comfort food at their best! Delightful for any special occasion.
Whoopie PIes
A classic Maine treat perfected by our bakers. Check out our seasonal flavors!
order online & ship nationwide
Get Two Fat Cats right to your door.

We ship pies anywhere in the continental United States via Goldbelly®!

Lancaster St., Portland, Maine

Newest location open July 4th, 2020! Stop by for all your favorite Two Fat Cats treats and new specialty items available for take-out or pre-order.

Hours & Directions

South Portland, Maine

Our SoPo location is just over the Casco Bay Bridge with all the classic Two Fat Cats treats, cakes and pies available for take-out or pre-order.

Hours & Directions