CAKES

Our cakes are rich, moist, & finished with a classic Italian buttercream. Our custom round layered cakes are made with 3 layers of cake with an optional filling, & frosting of your choice. Quarter Sheet & Half Sheet cakes are 2-layers with optional filling & choice of frosting. All custom cakes are made to order, so you can create your favorite flavor combination.

SIZES & SERVINGS

6_in_cake.png
6"
SERVES 6-8
$25
8"
SERVES 10-12
$35
10"
SERVES 16-20
$50
1/4 SHEET
20 SERVINGS
$50
1/2 SHEET
40 SERVINGS
$80

CUSTOM CAKES

FLAVORS

Chocolate
Vanilla

FILLINGS*

Strawberry
Raspberry
Lemon Curd
Coconut
Coconut-Pecan

FROSTINGS

Chocolate
Vanilla
Cream Cheese
Lemon*
Honey*
Mocha*
Peanut Butter*
American Vanilla Buttercream
*Fillings & Specialty Frosting + $6

Made just for you

We can write simple messages on most cakes at no additional charge. 
Looking for specialty or custom decorations? We’d love to learn more.
Reach out or email us at info@twofatcatsbakery.com with details on the size, type,  flavors of cake and any decoration examples. 

SIGNATURE CAKES

Our signature specialty cakes are perfect for any occasion. No substitutions or changes to specialty cakes; simple writing or decoration available.

6" $30   |   8" $40   |   10" $55

Fat Cat Lemon

Fat-Cat-Lemon-Cake.png

This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.

Carrot Cake

Fresh carrots, pecans, & golden raisins, topped with cream cheese frosting. Finished in a naked frosted style, Cream Cheese full frosting option +$6

Coconut Cake

Our classic vanilla cake with coconut filling, coconut buttercream frosting, covered with toasted coconut—for the coconut lover of course!

Fruit & Honey Cake

A beautiful vanilla cake layered with strawberry filling and vanilla pastry cream, finished with a honey sweetened buttercream frosting.

Red Velvet & Carrot Cakes are naked frosted

Red Velvet

Rich and delicious—this classic red velvet cake makes a statement layered with vanilla or cream cheese frosting. Finished in a naked frosted style, Cream Cheese full frosting option +$6

German Chocolate

Moist chocolate cake with layers of pecans and coconuts topped with chocolate buttercream and toasted coconut.

Chocolate Blackout Cake

Our Maine spin on this Brooklyn favorite with layered chocolate cake and homemade chocolate pudding covered in chocolate cake crumbs. 
Available in 6” or 8” only.

Holidays & Weekend Specials

In addition to our custom & specialty cakes, we have Holiday & Weekend Specials too!

Holidays and Weekend Specials flavors are available for limited time during specific dates for ordering & pickup. Check out our Local Preorder online menu and see what's new for Nationwide Shipping powered by Goldbelly®!

Orange-Creamsicle-Cake-and-slices.png